| Justin Theroux | Kevin Garvey |
| Amy Brenneman | Laurie Garvey |
| Christopher Eccleston | Matt Jamison |
| Liv Tyler | Meg Abbott |
| Margaret Qualley | Jill Garvey |
| Chris Zylka | Tom Garvey |
| Carrie Coon | Nora Durst |
| Ann Dowd | Patti Levin |
| Janel Moloney | Mary Jamison |
| Regina King | Erika Murphy |
| Kevin Carroll | John Murphy |
| Jovan Adepo | Michael Murphy |
| Jasmin Savoy Brown | Evangeline Murphy |
| Darius McCrary | Isaac Rayney |
| Betty Buckley | Jane |
| Bill Heck | Meg's Fiancé |
| Adina Porter | G.R. Leader |
| Violett Beane | Taylor |
| Kaci Beeler | Waitress |
| Kenneth Wayne Bradley | Miracle Ranger |
| Michael Clossin | Elderly Bartender |
| Laurie Coker | G.R. Elder 2 |
| Amy Dionne | G.R. Member |
| Katy Harris | Violet |
| Richard Jackson | G.R. Man in Glasses |
| Gregory Kelly | G.R. Guard at Gate |
| Marissa Luck | Cecilia-Wedding Dress |
| Josephine McAdam | Whistling G.R. Girl |
| Jason Newman | Bus Driver |
| Turk Pipkin | Pillar Man |
| Sam Stinson | Dirtbiker |
| Jamie Tisdale | Kristen |
| Danyelle Cavaness-Weatherford | G.R. Elder 3 |
| Mona Ricks | Lookyloo |
| Deborah Alcorn | Honky Tonk Patron |
| Dennis Alcorn | Honky Tonk Patron |
| Tuana Allen | Kid on the School Bus |
| Catt Bowen | Encampment Red Head |
| Johnathan Bowen | Encampment |
| Shane Honu Bryant | Undercover Guilty Remanent |
| Thomas Burke | Guilty Remnant |
| Carolee Crawford | Meg's Barn Posse |
| Ellen Crouch | Guilty Remnant |
| Diane Dearsan | Trailer Trash |
| Jarrod Dixon | Firefighter |
| Cherif Gacis | Church Attendee |
| Joshua Hawkins | Guilty Remnant |
| Mike Hickman | Remnant |
| Lisa Kaye | Restaurant Patron |
| R.C. Keene | Encampment resident |
| Stephen Latham | Meg's Barn Posse (Texas GR) |
| Laura L. Martin | Upscale Restaurant Patron |
| Artie Mozzone | Scoreboard Guard |
| Diane Mozzone | Scoreboard Guard |
| Sheryl Musgrove | Guilty Remnant- Meg's Barn Posse |
| Pamela L. Paek | Guilty Remnant |
| Chad Parma | Meg's Posse |
| Matthew Pogonat-Walters | Kid on School Bus |
| Dean Reading | Cowboy |
| Adriane Shown | Guilty Remnant |
| Cassandra Lynn Stubblefield | Traveler |
| Marilyn Swick | Upscale Restaurant Patron |
| Brian Towns | Encampment Biker |
| Ashley Turner | Tourist |
| Juliet Washington | Townsperson |
| Pamela A. Yarborough | Guilty Remnant |
| Heath Young | Tattooed Man |