| Jared Padalecki | Sam Winchester |
| Jensen Ackles | Dean Winchester |
| Rob Benedict | Chuck Shurley /
Carver Edlund |
| Emily Perkins | Becky Rosen |
| Devin Ratray | Damien /
'Dean' |
| Ernie Grunwald | Barnes /
'Sam' |
| Yan-Kay Crystal Lowe | Leticia Gore Actress
(as Crystal Lowe) |
| Teagan Rae Avoledo | Leticia Gore |
| Kayla Deorksen | LARP Maid
(as Kayla Doerksen) |
| John Shaw | Hotel Manager |
| Scott Patey | Alex |
| Amitai Marmorstein | Tim |
| Darien Provost | Little Boy |
| Connor Stanhope | Little Boy #1 |
| Connor Beardmore | Little Boy #2 |
| Luke Gair | Little Boy #3 |
| Jonathan Bruce | Convention Host |
| Paul Andrich | Killer Clown Fan |
| Ken Lawson | Fritz |