| Kathryn Morris | Lilly Rush |
| Danny Pino | Scotty Valens |
| John Finn | John Stillman |
| Jeremy Ratchford | Nick Vera |
| Thom Barry | Will Jeffries |
| Josh Hopkins | ADA Jason Kite |
| Geoffrey Lewis | Nathan 'Jonesy' Jones (2004) |
| Meta Golding | Sadie Douglas |
| Ryan Alosio | Pierce McClintock |
| Lou Beatty Jr. | Manross Delaney (2004) |
| Sven Holmberg | Frankie (2004) |
| Lillian Lehman | Blanche Debbins (2004) |
| Leslie Silva | Sarah Tucker |
| Adam Weiner | Nathan 'Jonesy' Jones (1939) |
| Ryan Francis | Frankie (2004) |
| Grant Garrison | |
| Keke Palmer | Arlene (1939) |
| Nadine Ellis | Blanche (1939) |
| Zoe Cotton | Arlene (2004) |
| Mattilyn Rochester Kravitz | Woman #3 |
| Shacolby Randell | Manross (1939) |
| Dennis W. Hall | Clerk |
| Tom Knickerbocker | Clive |
| Anne Marie Howard | Jennifer |
| Dan Desmond | Barnsley |