| Amybeth McNulty | Anne Shirley |
| Matt Willis | Tradesman |
| Geraldine James | Marilla Cuthbert |
| R.H. Thomson | Matthew Cuthbert |
| Dalila Bela | Diana Barry |
| Corrine Koslo | Rachel Lynde |
| Aymeric Jett Montaz | Jerry Baynard |
| Ian D. Clark | Stationmaster
(as Ian Clark) |
| Jonathan Holmes | Mr. William Barry |
| Helen Johns | Mrs. Eliza Barry |
| Sarah Dodd | Matron |
| Dan Warry-Smith | Stablemaster |
| Philip Williams | Thomas Lynde
(as Phillip Williams) |
| Ryan Kiera Armstrong | Minnie May Barry |
| Torquil Colbo | Sam |
| Michael Crawford | Sammy |
| Alden Adair | Shady Man |
| Rob Ramsay | Mr. Avery |
| Daniel Kash | Pawnbroker |
| Tyler Barish | Newsie |
| Helen Taylor | Wealthy Lady |
| Andrea Creighton | Maid |
| Leanne Miller | Scullery Maid |
| Zenna Davis-Jones | Young Woman |
| Matt Willis | Tradesman |
| Katelyn Wells | Mary Joe |
| Norman Owen | Man
(as Norm Owen) |
| Merle Newell | Woman |
| Brian Tree | Minister |
| David Ingram | Mr. Andrews |
| Janet Porter | Mrs. Andrews |
| Ella Jonas Farlinger | Prissy Andrews |
| Lia Pappas-Kemps | Jane Andrews |
| Christian Martyn | Billy Andrews |
| Porter Schaefer | Little Boy
(as Porter Christopher Schaefer) |
| Zoe McGarry | Girl #2
(archive footage) (uncredited) |
| Avery Trask | Girl #1
(archive footage) (uncredited) |
| Marissa Kate Wilson | Young Woman's Friend
(uncredited) |