| Mandy Patinkin | Jason Gideon |
| Thomas Gibson | Aaron Hotchner |
| Lola Glaudini | Elle Greenaway |
| Shemar Moore | Derek Morgan |
| Matthew Gray Gubler | Dr. Spencer Reid |
| A.J. Cook | Jennifer Jareau |
| Neal Jones | Karl Arnold |
| Tony Todd | Eric Miller |
| Bonita Friedericy | Dr. Rachel Howard |
| Abraham Benrubi | Frank Fielding |
| Meredith Monroe | Haley Hotchner |
| Kirsten Vangsness | Penelope Garcia |
| Chane't Johnson | Barbara Raleigh |
| Allison Dunbar | Allison Crawford |
| Dameon Clarke | Chris Crawford |
| Warren Davis | Harry Dunken |
| Jacqueline Mazarella | Robin Dunken |
| Sharisse Baker-Bernard | Fay Arnold |
| Leith M. Burke | Michael Kapp
(as Leith Burke) |
| Roberto 'Sanz' Sanchez | SWAT Guy
(as Roberto Sanchez) |
| Dana Emberson | Unsub |
| Emma Polhemus | Emily Crawford |
| Colton Shires | Sam Crawford |
| Alexandra Wyshak | Jackie Dunken |
| Chaise Goris | Sarah Arnold |
| Zach Fischer | Karl Arnold Jr.
(as Zackary M. Fisher) |
| Kathleen Carr | Dead Mrs. Miller
(as Kathleen Marie Carr) |
| Elizabeth Chambers | Elizabeth Chambers |
| Valerie Anastasias | BAU Special Agent Harrison
(uncredited) |
| Jon Barton | SWAT Leader
(uncredited) |
| Ronald McAdams | Unsub
(uncredited) |